Questions that Provoke Reflection
September 27, 2024
By Mike Steklof, Ed.D.

When I hear the name Hillel, my thoughts drift to two powerful entities: Rabbi Hillel, the sage whose wisdom continues to guide us, and Hillel of Buffalo, an organization that nurtures Jewish life at Buffalo area colleges. Each Hillel embodies a vital aspect of our community: one rooted in profound teachings and the other in active engagement. As the Interim Campus Director of Hillel of Buffalo, my connection to both the sage and the organization grows deeper each day.

Rabbi Hillel famously said, “If I am not for myself, who will be for me? If I am only for myself, what am I? And if not now, when?” (Pirkei Avot 1:14) These words resonate deeply, not just because of their wisdom, but also because they hold personal significance for me; my brother has them tattooed on his body, a constant reminder of their importance.

These statements might seem like mere advice, yet they are framed as questions. This style of communication reflects the rich tradition of Talmudic debate. Hillel’s questions invite us into a dialogue with ourselves—a self-inquiry that is particularly relevant during the High Holy Days.

We are called to look after ourselves, care for others, and act now. But why does Hillel express these ideas as questions? Perhaps it is to provoke thought and reflection. This season of introspection encourages us to examine our own lives, our relationships, and our commitments.

Imagine Hillel the Elder standing before you today. Can you identify one area in your life that needs attention during this High Holy Day period?

Now, imagine Hillel speaking your name, gently asking you his three pivotal questions:
• “If you are not for yourself, who will be for you?”
• “But if you are only for yourself, what are you?”
• “And if not now, when?”

These questions are not just rhetorical; they challenge us to take responsibility for our own well-being while remaining mindful of our impact on others. They compel us to act and to reflect on the interconnectedness of our lives.

As we navigate this season of reflection, let us embrace Hillel’s wisdom. May we strive to find balance: caring for ourselves while also reaching out to those around us. Let us act now, so that we may strengthen not only our own lives but also our communities.

 

Mike Steklof, Ed.D. is the Interim Campus Director of Hillel of Buffalo.